David Brooks vs Multiculturalism

David Brooks is just an idiot. What else can I say?

David Brooks: The Death of Multiculturalism - New York Times

In 1994 multiculturalism was at its high-water mark, and Richard Bernstein wrote “Dictatorship of Virtue,” describing its excesses: the campus speech codes, the forced sensitivity training, the purging of dead white males from curriculums, the people who had their careers ruined by dubious charges of racism, sexism and ethnocentrism.

Then two years later, the liberal writer Michael Tomasky published “Left for Dead,” which argued that the progressive movement was being ruined by multicultural identity politics. Democrats have lost the ability to talk to Americans collectively, Tomasky wrote, and seem to be a collection of aggrieved out-groups: feminists, blacks, gays and so on.

...
That's because over the past few years, multiculturalism has faded away. A different sort of liberalism is taking over the Democratic Party.

Multiculturalism is in decline for a number of reasons. First, the identity groups have ossified. The feminist organizations were hypocritical during the Clinton impeachment scandal, and both fevered and weak during the Roberts and Alito hearings. Meanwhile, the civil rights groups have become stale and uninteresting.

Interesting assertions here, Mr. Brooks. Do you have any evidence regarding fevered yet weak feminist groups? And stale and uninteresting civil rights. Hmmm. Do you mean uninteresting to you? Or what?

Brooks blathers on:

Second, the Democrats have come to understand that they need to pay less attention to minorities and more to the white working class if they ever want to become the majority party again. Third, the intellectual energy on the left is now with the economists.

I suppose he is referring, in his backhand manner, to Paul Krugman and Brad DeLong, and even maybe Atrios?

oh, here we go:

Fourth and most important, 9/11 happened. The attacks aroused feelings of national solidarity, or a longing for national solidarity, that discredited the multiculturalists' tribalism.

Uh huh. Right. One tribe, all in favor of illegal wiretapping, corporate corruption, torture, and fiscal mismanagement. Maybe our tribe is going to be based instead around our new mantra: 603!

There's more, but why bother.

Tags:

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Seth A. published on April 27, 2006 8:37 AM.

Stuck With Bushy was the previous entry in this blog.

How Bob Marley Caught Fire is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Pages

Powered by Movable Type 4.37